Dear comrade,

Dear comrade,
Image of the Cat's Eye Nebula: ESA, NASA, HEIC and The Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA)

Diving into and interpreting stories is a little beyond me right now. I sit down at the computer and look at these volumes of stories William Jones collected, so many of which I haven't even read yet, but I find myself just flipping through them aimlessly so I thought I would try a letter instead, just sort out my thoughts. I'm reading Nation of Strangers by Turkish author Ece Temelkuran, it is written as a collection of letters. Dear Stranger. Not as a way to create distance, but stranger as a place of connection. We are, all of us, strangers trying to build worlds together while holding onto relationships to land and history. So if it's ok with you, I'm going to adopt this practice as I work through my grief, but not as strangers trying to build a home together, because I haven't the capacity to build anything right now. Rather as comrades who are, for better or worse, in this together. Which is what this essay is about, finding the language I needed to communicate the impossible.

In May, I returned to the story of the Fisher Star and then I vanished into an endless winter. The birds were trapped somewhere and I could not hear them, my world shrinking as a result, their song becoming an increasingly distant horizon across a darkening landscape I could not cross. Or perhaps it was me that stopped singing, trapped in a cage inside a house in a village far from where I was meant to be. Perhaps I stopped singing, I definitely stopped writing. Hot takes on social media, Facebook mostly, Kassandra shouting into the wind, but that isn't really writing. That's just shots fired into the dark. Rage is an effective, if overly blunt, weapon with which to punch through the layers of grief. Other emotions are too soft for such work.

I've taken to calling it the lost summer. But it was a lost year really as my mother's needs expanded and eventually consumed me before the inevitable collapse.

When the core runs out of hydrogen fuel, [the star] will contract under the weight of gravity. However, some hydrogen fusion will occur in the upper layers. As the core contracts, it heats up. This heats the upper layers, causing them to expand. As the outer layers expand, the radius of the star will increase and it will become a red giant.

The Death of a Star, Craig Freudenrich, Ph.D.

We'd gone out for afternoon tea for her birthday in April 2025 and she didn't eat much, she always felt full whether she ate or not. We'd tried a number of over the counter and natural remedies with no success so in May she went to her doctor, and then a specialist who sent her for a colonoscopy. It was cancer. We sat for hours of chemo and waited for radiation and scans but a year after the initial doctor's appointment it became clear that surgery wasn't an option and my mother told her oncologist she didn't want further treatment. There is Jack, she would say. There was always Jack. She was my (step) father's primary caregiver but with her health deteriorating by the day it became impossible and a month later he moved into assisted living. She followed him two weeks later.

By late July she was gone.

Five weeks later, he followed her.

I was not prepared for the grief that consumed me. I was not prepared for the cage or the house or the village that existed somewhere outside of me far beyond reach. I was not prepared for the expansion and contraction of a dying star.

Venus is the second planet from the Sun, and Earth's closest planetary neighbor. Venus is the third brightest object in the sky after the Sun and Moon. Venus spins slowly in the opposite direction from most planets. ~ NASA, Venus Facts

This is not a maudlin essay about her final year full of new memories and small joys, twirling and laughing in soft focus. I read Darkover Landfall aloud while plastic bags slid carefully metred poison into her veins, editing the more problematic or annoying sections on the go. We shopped at Farmboy when Costco became too much. Eventually it was all too much. This essay, this letter, is about my search for language to process it all.

My Ojibwe father, Roy-ba, named me for the planet Venus, calling me the Morning Star because I was born in the morning.

My mother and I had a fraught relationship. It wasn't complicated. It was fraught. There were landmines everywhere, inexplicable rages with aftershocks that lingered for decades, but there is an archaic meaning as well that is equally true. Something that is fraught was once considered to be well supplied or provided. I have wonderful memories of my mother, she was my biggest cheerleader and believed beyond all good sense that I was not only the best but the brightest. The problem is that so many of these memories are veiled with darkness because of what often accompanied them. I learned very early that whether filled with joy or fear, the emotions that careened about within her were made manifest because of things I did or failed to do.

I understand now that much of it was an expression of her own trauma, but children don't understand that and it's in childhood that the scaffolding of our emotional life is laid. So remembering her honestly a bit of an archeological dig if you will, an excavation to inspect the damage as well as rescue artifacts of great value before they are buried in the collapse. I was prepared for sadness, for relief, for a sense of ending. I was not prepared for the all consuming grief ... to be a bird in the story of the Fisher Star.

At some point after this, the core will become hot enough to cause the helium to fuse into carbon. When the helium fuel runs out, the core will expand and cool. The upper layers will expand and eject material that will collect around the dying star to form a planetary nebula. Finally, the core will cool into a white dwarf and then eventually into a black dwarf. This entire process will take a few billion years.

The Death of a Star, Craig Freudenrich, Ph.D.

My mother was the sun. My father circled close as Mercury. Despite its proximity to the Sun, Mercury is actually colder than Venus because it lacks an atmosphere to hold the heat. Perhaps that's why it circles so closely, unable to hold onto the heat for itself it must stay near the source.

The rain in Death Valley rarely touches the ground, it is so hot that the moisture just evaporates back into the cloud. The sulphuric acid that rains on Venus does the same thing, the intense heat causing it to evaporate back into the atmosphere for an endless cycle of caustic rain that never reaches the planet's surface. Scientists think that the planet might have been different millions of years ago but a runaway greenhouse effect changed everything, as such effects are prone to do. The upper atmosphere is, bizarrely, considered to be habitable and some bright minds are gazing at it like they've never seen a space disaster movie.

I can relate to all that. The intensity of that heat, the cycling acid, the runaway greenhouse effect, the narrow band that is almost habitable. And a very small planet between me and the sun doing its best to absorb some of that heat but not being able to. Well done dad.

And then she was gone.

The thought of planning a service of any sort was beyond me, not only because of my grief but because she had shined so brightly for those who were at the best and safest distance to orbit. I was Venus, the morning star. Rotating in a different direction. Consumed by the expansion of a dying sun and then suddenly in the dark and unfamiliar cold that followed the contraction. I had no words. It was beyond my ability to listen to those who had basked in her warmth while I choked on cycling acid whenever I ventured or stumbled outside of that narrow habitable band.

So I told people that I would do it when he was gone as well, because it did make sense to remember them together. But that wasn't the real reason, I can admit that to you comrades because we're in this together. Had somebody offered to do the labour I would have refused. What I needed was distance, to get used to the idea and find a way to listen to those who lived far enough from the sun to feel the warmth on their face without fearing the scorching acid that comes when you step too far. I had to find words.

The star collapses by its own gravity and the iron core heats up. The core becomes so tightly packed that protons and electrons merge to form neutrons. In less than a second, the iron core, which is about the size of Earth, shrinks to a neutron core with a radius of about 6 miles (10 kilometers). The outer layers of the star fall inward on the neutron core, thereby crushing it further. The core heats to billions of degrees and explodes (supernova), thereby releasing large amounts of energy and material into space.

The Death of a Star, Craig Freudenrich, Ph.D.

I read Arundhati Roy's memoir Mother Mary Comes to Me at the suggestion of my friend Fiona. Roy also had a fraught relationship with her mother and I knew that which is why I had avoided the book when it first came out. Can't have feelings if you avoid the things that give them to you. But then Fiona recommended it right around the time my mother passed, and I decided to give it a go.

Now we've arrived at the point of all this. Stories give us the words for things we find impossible to communicate. They give us phrases and pictures. Seeing myself as Venus or the trapped birds gives me a path out, or a way to understand what is happening. I think about that story often, but always about the animals and their courage and organizing across difference. I didn't think about the birds. About how small their world had gotten, how quiet. how dark.

Arundhati Roy described her mother as her shelter and her storm, a woman who was able to shine brightly for others because she and her brother absorbed their mother's darkness. Mrs. Roy was by all accounts an abusive and terrifying woman who was also a fearsome advocate for the rights of women and girls, particularly regarding the right to inherit property and have an education. There are laws in India about these things because of Mrs. Roy. But there are also scars and triggers that linger in those she mistreated. This isn't about cancelling, this is about reconciling, finding the language to capture both parts of a person in some kind of cohesive whole.

Like Mrs. Roy, my mother was a whole person. I need to be able to grieve the whole person. I need to be able to grieve the knowledge that we will never have the relationship we should have, and I need to know there wasn't anything I could have done about it. And I need to be able to do that without continuing to absorb her darkness so that others can bask in the glimmers of light their own memories provide.

The shock wave from the supernova can initiate star formation in other interstellar clouds. The remains of the core can form a neutron star or a black hole depending upon the mass of the original star.

The Death of a Star, Craig Freudenrich, Ph.D.

In the months before she passed my mother talked about getting a tattoo of a bluebird. I wasn't sure about it, she was 83 and her skin was fragile and thin, but I asked my tattoo artist about it. She has a very light hand, which I have appreciated, and has done tattoos on elderly people before so she said she would love to do one for my mom. My mom deteriorated quickly, the tattoo didn't happen. Not on her skin anyway.

After her passing I got a tattoo of a tree with roots mirroring the branches in full leaf, each tree with a bluebird in it. One tree is this world, the other is the next. Like any story it can be read in different ways depending on what you focus on, depending on my mood. I like to think that she is finally free of the cages that trapped her, singing back winter so the fresh worlds of spring can burst forth.

We can be multiple things in multiple stories, and the collapse of a star doesn't have to mean the unknown void of a black hole. It can form a neutron star; fantastically powerful stars scattered across the universe in the form of pulsars and magnetars, another form of life bursting free from the old.

Comrades, if it's ok with you I'm going to keep sending these letters while I process my grief, because there has been so much grief in the past few years and I don't mean this only in the broad political sense or the losses of celebrities who meant something to us although those things are real too. I mean the kind of grief I should probably go to therapy for, but since that isn't going to happen I'll write instead. This loss lands after a series of other losses, communities and ideas who may have cushioned my fall but not really if I'm honest about it. I'll talk more about that another time. Not so much analysis of stories for a bit, I haven't the capacity for that right now, but a grasping about for something to hold onto. A point of connection between me and the old ones, between me and you, and perhaps a star to guide us home.

baamaapii

CTA Image

Everything BIBC has been moved to it's own page! Places you can see me, listen to interviews and podcasts, read endorsements and reviews. You can get my books at any independent bookstore as well as the Big Names who shame remain nameless. King's Bookstore in Halifax will ship your order across Canada for a flat rate of $5 which is bonkers. Please do support them. They also have a books beyond bars initiative that supplies books to a women's prison. I love that.

And if you want me to zoom into your local bookstore or bookclub, talk with you on your podcast I can do that. Send an email to patty.krawec@gmail.com For larger professional settings you can email Rob Firing at rob@transatlanticagency.com

Learn more about Bad Indians Book Club